Skip to main content

Main Secondary Navigation

  • About Ateneo de Manila
  • Schools
  • Research
  • Global
  • Alumni
  • News
  • Events

Main navigation

  • Learn & Grow
  • Discover & Create
  • Make an Impact
  • Campus & Community
  • Apply
  • Home >
  • News >
  • [Blueboard] The 2021 Code of Conduct for the South China Sea: Navigating between norms and power politics

[Blueboard] The 2021 Code of Conduct for the South China Sea: Navigating between norms and power politics

10 Aug 2021 | Alma Maria O. Salvador

 

South China Sea

Renewed interest and hopes for a final Code of Conduct for the South China Sea have surfaced during the 37th ASEAN Summit. The focus is on moving forward an “effective and substantive” code from the Single Draft Negotiating Text (SDNT) that forms part of the latest agreement between ASEAN-China leaders as of 2019. This should have been seen as a positive turn for ASEAN and China relations in the light of establishing a rules based governance and dispute settlement system for the users/ littoral states in the region. However bilateral developments marked by China’s aggression against claimant member states before and during the pandemic have pushed the claimant states of ASEAN to resort to legal measures outside of the yet evolving regional code arrangement.

Between 2017 and 2018 when the Framework and the SDNT were formulated, China has upped the ante of making counterclaims against its own in this vital waterway. During the pandemic,Chinese navies, coast guards and fishing vessels’ deployment of complex military and militia tactics of firing water cannons, swarming and ramming against Philippine,Vietnamese and Malaysian fishing and oil exploration vessels have resulted in parallel militarism among ASEAN member states including the Philippines. One of the more recent forms of intimidation in 2019 was the swarming of hundreds of Chinese military-non military vessels in Pag-asa Island in the West Philippine Sea, where Philippine military and civilians established a community.

But the real tensions between parties are actually found in the provisions  of the draft. The future of negotiations for what is hoped to be an enforceable regional code will have to address the polar views of China and individual ASEAN member states on framing the SCS as exclusive to the littoral states of the waterway or as part of the global commons. Needless to say China is the proponent of exclusivity in the SCS. Alternatively, the latter view which seeks to guarantee freedom of the seas and navigation has the support of Malaysia, Vietnam and the Philippines.  Another thorny issue is China’s non recognition of the UN arbitral ruling of 2016 (Philippines vs China) which is detrimental for a governance regime anchored on the UN Law of the Sea Convention. Failure to align the code to the UNCLOS and the arbitral ruling is the first bottleneck for an effective dispute settlement arrangement in the SCS. Vietnam is most vocal about implementing an UNCLOS-aligned code of conduct. Given the asymmetrical nature of power play in the negotiations and the facts on the ground, could the horizon for an effective code of conduct be far behind?

How regional parties bridge competing ideas in the code poses a major challenge. The first set of these includes the narratives already mentioned in the preferences of parties for or against aligning the code to the UNCLOS and hence to the practice of freedom of navigation. These issues mirror the politics and ideologies of China and are mobilizing points for counter US involvement. This is thus an example of how an interface of norms and great power politics can dangerously impact on the region.

On the other hand, are practical cooperative measures that are proposed in the draft notably, to advance marine environmental protection, research, safety of navigation and communication at sea, transnational crimes, search and rescue and resource exploration, when implemented at bilateral and mini-lateral levels within ASEAN will help build confidence and maritime security among users. These practical arrangements also serve to cushion the limitations of a code that is increasingly being embedded in a precarious geopolitical environment. 

Under the current circumstances, ASEAN may not be able to fully depend on an enforceable code of conduct that incorporates global rules and norms and the voices of smaller claimant states vis-a-vis China’s revisionism. In addition to this, ASEAN should strengthen the cooperative security institutions it has built overtime. Revisiting ASEAN way in order to strengthen ASEAN centrality is a pragmatic move as well as strengthening of defense level security arrangements such as the ASEAN Defense Ministers Meeting (ADMM)- Plus to further practical cooperation in jointly safeguarding against the unintended consequences of asymmetrical power relations in the SCS.

Alma Maria O. Salvador PhD is a full time member of the Ateneo de Manila University Department of Political Science.

Blueboard

 

Geography History International and Area Studies Political Science Public Administration and Policy Security and Diplomacy Academics Internationalization Research, Creativity, and Innovation Rosita G Leong School of Social Sciences
Share:

Recent News

ACRI's Dr Percival Lao awarded DGD Scholarship for MSc in Global One Health at the Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp and the University of Pretoria

07 Feb 2026

1st grader Charlotte Saluta captures 4 golds at TMC Gymnastics Meet

07 Feb 2026

Ateneo Art Gallery presents the "Moving Image Program" this February to March: A series of films and talks surrounding the moving image as a medium in contemporary art practice

06 Feb 2026

Call for Applications: Main Concessionaires for all Basic Education (BE) Cafeterias 2026 (UBAO Memo)

06 Feb 2026

What's New, SOH? December 2025–January 2026 Edition

06 Feb 2026

Sapang Palay outreach: Ateneo parents for and with others

06 Feb 2026

ASoG, through the Ateneo Policy Center, delivers 26 publications in 2025

06 Feb 2026

Graduate Scholarship Application Deadlines for SY 2026-2027 (OAVP-GE Memo)

06 Feb 2026

Lighting Up the Future: Liter of Light sets Guinness World Record with solar-powered display in Manila

06 Feb 2026

ASOG MPM Doctors to the Barrios renew commitment to public service

06 Feb 2026

Pagination

  • First page « First
  • Previous page ‹ Previous
  • …
  • Page 136
  • Page 137
  • Page 138
  • Page 139
  • Page 140
  • Page 141
  • Page 142
  • Page 143
  • Page 144
  • …
  • Next page Next ›
  • Last page Last »

You may also like these articles

Ateneo Policy Center presents study on local health spending at DBM Fiscal Policy Conference 2026

17 Nov 2026

Ateneo Policy Center presents study on local health spending at DBM Fiscal Policy Conference 2026

On 19 October 2026, the Ateneo School of Government, through its research and policy unit, the Ateneo Policy Center (APC), presented findings from a study

APC hosts brownbag session on Southern Philippines maritime security

14 Nov 2026

APC hosts brownbag session on Southern Philippines maritime security

On 19 October 2026, the Ateneo School of Government (ASOG), through its research and policy unit, the Ateneo Policy Center (APC), and in partnership with

LHF

13 Nov 2026

Turning health resources into services: ASOG conducts executive education course on health financing and public financial management

The Ateneo School of Government (ASOG) conducted Understanding Local Health Financing and Public Financial Management for Universal Health Care Implementation, a two-day executive education course

ASOG and VMLP Quezon Chapter Strengthen Legislative Leadership Through PILLAR Program Module on Session Management

13 Nov 2026

ASOG and VMLP Quezon Chapter Strengthen Legislative Leadership Through PILLAR Program Module on Session Management

The Ateneo School of Government (ASOG) through its Executive Education Center, in partnership with the Vice Mayors’ League of the Philippines (VMLP) – Quezon Provincial

Tickets available for Heiwa no Senritsu

13 Nov 2026

Tickets available for Heiwa no Senritsu: Mga Himig ng Kapayapaan

Tickets are now available for the upcoming orchestral concert, Heiwa no Senritsu: Mga Himig ng Kapayapaan, which will take place on 8 December 2026, 7:00

Eagle1

11 Nov 2026

ASOG Memo No. 2627-34 - Commencement Speaker 2026

Memo #2627-34 11 November 2026 TO : The Ateneo de Manila Community in Higher Education FROM : [Sgd.] JENNIFER S. ORETA, PhD Dean, Ateneo School

Katipunan Avenue, Loyola Heights, Quezon City 1108, Philippines

info@ateneo.edu

+63 2 8426 6001

Connect With Us
  • Contact Ateneo
  • A to Z Directory
  • Social Media
Information for
  • Current Students
  • Prospective Students
  • International Students
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Alumni
  • Researchers & Visiting Academics
  • Parents
  • Donors & Partners
  • Visitors & Media
  • Careers
Security & Emergency
  • COVID-19
  • Campus Safety
  • Network & Tech
  • Emergency Management
  • Disaster Preparedness
Digital Resources
  • AteneoBlueCloud
  • Archium
  • Rizal Library
  • Ateneo Mail (Staff)
  • Ateneo Student Email
  • Alumni Mail
  • Branding & Trademarks
  • Data Privacy
  • Acceptable Use Policy
  • Report Website Issues
  • Ateneo Network
  • Philippine Jesuits

Copyright © 2022 Ateneo de Manila University. All rights reserved. | info@ateneo.edu | +63 2 8426 6001

Search